Hey Everyone!
So I'm finally caught up on Doctor Who. so i guess I'll give my opinion on the show
There will be spoilers abunches in this post
First off, I Liked Tennant. He was easily my favorite of the 3 (does john hurt count as a doctor?) doctors, Eccleston was good but not enough personality, and Matt smith had some fun time but he was batshyte crazy for most of the episodes and would contradict himself so often.
I think i preferred the Russel T Davies seasons over the Moffat era. I have a lot of respect for Moffat because of Sherlock, but the last couple seasons weren't all that well written. I loved the 2 part episodes and futuristic worlds. I swear every episode in the last few seasons was in the past, It's like the costume designer wanted to make period costumes for their showreel. I Loved the Vasta Narada episode, and the one on the diamond planet, both are tennant. but after smith and Moffat took over almost every episode was in the past and a rehash of old creatures. though i liked the upgraded Cyberman episode, I felt no urgency in it at all.
So ma y of the episodes have the doctor just randomly showing up, solving an issue that was randomly there, then randomly jetting off. I kinda hate this style of tv. I love continuing stories, and I really liked the few Multi episode arcs, the Master saga at the end of one of the seasons was great, 3 episodes all following the same story.
I get that the doctor is a random character, but Its annoying how he just pops in randomly, solves the problem and pops off. then at the end the storyline is resolved in the finale, kind of.
Overall I enjoyed the series and I got a bit hooked during the center of the series but near the last couple season I just wanted to get to the end. I understand why people like it but it's not worth the raving fangirl Squees that I hear at every convention.
Anyway, I'll do a few rankings.
Doctors:
1. David Tennant, 10:
2. Matt Smith, 11:
3. christopher eccleston, 9:
Companions:
1. Amy/Rory
2. Clara
3. Martha
4. Rose
5. Donna
I dont know if i should include River song, but she'd be way up there
Creatures
1. Vashta Narada
2. Oods
3. Silurians
4. the Clockwork droid? the one that wore a venetian mask
5. Weeping angels
So I'm finally caught up on Doctor Who. so i guess I'll give my opinion on the show
There will be spoilers abunches in this post
First off, I Liked Tennant. He was easily my favorite of the 3 (does john hurt count as a doctor?) doctors, Eccleston was good but not enough personality, and Matt smith had some fun time but he was batshyte crazy for most of the episodes and would contradict himself so often.
I think i preferred the Russel T Davies seasons over the Moffat era. I have a lot of respect for Moffat because of Sherlock, but the last couple seasons weren't all that well written. I loved the 2 part episodes and futuristic worlds. I swear every episode in the last few seasons was in the past, It's like the costume designer wanted to make period costumes for their showreel. I Loved the Vasta Narada episode, and the one on the diamond planet, both are tennant. but after smith and Moffat took over almost every episode was in the past and a rehash of old creatures. though i liked the upgraded Cyberman episode, I felt no urgency in it at all.
So ma y of the episodes have the doctor just randomly showing up, solving an issue that was randomly there, then randomly jetting off. I kinda hate this style of tv. I love continuing stories, and I really liked the few Multi episode arcs, the Master saga at the end of one of the seasons was great, 3 episodes all following the same story.
I get that the doctor is a random character, but Its annoying how he just pops in randomly, solves the problem and pops off. then at the end the storyline is resolved in the finale, kind of.
Overall I enjoyed the series and I got a bit hooked during the center of the series but near the last couple season I just wanted to get to the end. I understand why people like it but it's not worth the raving fangirl Squees that I hear at every convention.
Anyway, I'll do a few rankings.
Doctors:
1. David Tennant, 10:
2. Matt Smith, 11:
3. christopher eccleston, 9:
Companions:
1. Amy/Rory
2. Clara
3. Martha
4. Rose
5. Donna
I dont know if i should include River song, but she'd be way up there
Creatures
1. Vashta Narada
2. Oods
3. Silurians
4. the Clockwork droid? the one that wore a venetian mask
5. Weeping angels
Comments
Post a Comment